On November 18, 2026, the Michigan Court of Appeals held that a buyer that accepts goods must pay the contract price, even if alleging a breach by the supplier. Disputes over offsets and supplier-performance damages should be resolved without allowing an offset to result in nonpayment for accepted goods.
Background
JAC Products, Inc. was an automotive supplier, and Demmak Industries, LLC, as Iridium Manufacturing, made parts for JAC. They had two agreements where Iridium agreed to supply all of JAC’s needs per JAC's purchase orders.
The terms specified that JAC’s forecasts were nonbinding and deliveries followed JAC’s schedules. JAC could adjust quantities and terminate for convenience, with payment limited to completed, unpaid goods and work-in-process, excluding anticipated profits and losses.
After ending the relationship in April 2023, JAC notified Iridium of its plan to “short pay” to recover about $130,930 for alleged late delivery costs. Iridium sued for $428,252.10, including $121,284.19 for unpaid delivered products. JAC counterclaimed for supplier-performance damages.
The Court of Appeals ruled the contracts were requirements contracts. The agreements bound Iridium to supply JAC’s needs, while estimates and forecasts did not create fixed purchase commitments. The court highlighted the agreements’ language making estimates nonbinding and requiring supply per JAC’s schedules.
Iridium argued JAC’s delays were material breaches preventing JAC from enforcing its rights. However, the court stated the dispute fell under Article 2 of the UCC, and Iridium did not present an argument under Article 2 to support its position.
A Buyer Cannot Obtain a Double Recovery Through an Offset
The Court of Appeals reversed JAC’s counterclaim judgment because JAC withheld $121,284.19 for delivered products as an offset against its claimed damages. The trial court allowed JAC to obtain a judgment for damages while keeping unpaid goods, creating an improper windfall. The appellate court remanded to prevent double recovery.
The court upheld the UCC rule that a buyer must pay the contract rate for accepted goods. A buyer seeking recovery for nonconforming performance must pursue remedies consistent with that payment obligation; acceptance does not allow nonpayment for accepted goods.
Practical Implications for Automotive and Other Supply-Chain Participants
The decision provides key insights for buyers and suppliers in purchase orders and supply arrangements.
First, labels do not determine contract type. A blanket purchase order can be a requirements contract if it aligns quantity with the buyer’s needs and treats forecasts as nonbinding. A release-by-release arrangement may exist without a fixed quantity commitment.
Second, even nonbinding estimates and forecasts are significant. Under the UCC, they can guide good-faith requirements. Agreements should clearly label estimates as planning tools and outline the effects of demand changes.
Third, termination rights, quantity changes, and damage limits must comply with UCC payment rules. Buyers with valid damage claims should separate payment for accepted goods from recoverable damages and setoff rights to prevent double recovery.
Finally, suppliers asserting that buyer conduct excused performance should reference the relevant UCC theory instead of common-law material-breach principles. Contract language, performance history, accepted goods, notice, and remedy limitations can all affect the analysis.
Practical Pointers
State the intended quantity commitment clearly.
If the parties intend a requirements contract, use express language and specify whether the supplier is awarded all or a percentage of the buyer’s requirements.
Draft forecasts and estimates with precision.
Specify whether forecasts are binding, partially binding, or informational. If intended for capacity planning, address the forecast horizon, permitted deviation, update frequency, and consequences of demand changes.
Align release language with the commercial deal.
Terms stating “firm quantities” in releases can support a release-based process but should reconcile with program-award language promising a percentage of buyer requirements.
Document changes, shortages, and production constraints contemporaneously.
A party claiming the other caused delays should keep written records of shortages, release changes, missed deliveries, quality issues, and communications regarding mitigation.
Give clear breach notice.
For accepted goods, Michigan’s UCC requires the buyer to notify the seller of a claimed breach promptly or risk being barred from a remedy. Notice should indicate a breach exists and preserve an opportunity to resolve the dispute.
Separate payment obligations from disputed damage claims.
Before withholding payment for accepted goods, confirm the contract’s setoff language and assess the accounting consequences of any offset. A damages claim should not lead to both a judgment for the full claimed loss and retention of the unpaid value of accepted goods.
Review termination provisions before acting.
A termination-for-convenience clause should cover notice, work-in-process, completed goods, buyer-furnished property, transition obligations, and the relationship between termination payments and breach claims. Suppliers should evaluate whether remedy limitations leave them with a workable allocation of termination risk.
Demmak Industries, LLC d/b/a Iridium Manufacturing v JAC Products, Inc, unpublished opinion per curiam of the Court of Appeals, decided November 18, 2026 (Docket No. 377081).


/Passle/6ac4b89d2b3863124008f029/SearchServiceImages/2026-11-19-12-07-41-285-6afee68df00d200e875a2261.jpg)
/Passle/6ac4b89d2b3863124008f029/SearchServiceImages/2026-11-18-18-27-51-212-6afdee27f00d200e8757c25a.jpg)
/Passle/6ac4b89d2b3863124008f029/SearchServiceImages/2026-11-18-17-21-02-531-6afdde7eff5130799d051f60.jpg)